All my brown eyeliners

1. Eyeliner INGLOT Matte Collection AMC Eyeliner Gel No. 90 waterproof brown


My opinion: It did not spread along the edges of the jar - I just had it for a long time and after a while it “cracked” in half, I had to melt it a little. Serves as well as before. The color is deep brown. The eyeliner is sooo long-lasting, can only be washed off with a 2-phase waterproof make-up remover (see below). I really like her when it comes to the beach or the pool (yes, yes, even there I look up)
Grade: 5+
Price: in the region of 500 r.
Usage: 1 year

2. INGLOT Liquid Eyeliner brown # 23


My opinion: The eyeliner works very well, but at the end of the day the tip of the arrow may fade a little (just a little), but generally lasts all day. Works well on shadows. At a time, you can draw 2 arrows at once, if you do not hesitate, the applicator does not dry out during this time.
Grade: 5-
Price: 500 p.
Usage: 10 months

3. MAC Superslick Liquid Eye Liner # Defiantly Feline


My opinion: Decent eyeliner, but there are also disadvantages: when applied, if a little gets on the eyelashes, they stick together - instantly; when washed off with a wash (simple or waterproof) - it peels off in pieces, which is not very convenient.
Now the pluses: resistant in contact with water, At the end of the day does not go anywhere, a good rich brown color with a little shimir. Previously, I was a little annoyed by her silicone (or whatever it was) brush, but then I realized that it was even a class. Draws only one arrow at a time, then you need to dip it so that it does not dry out.
Grade: 4
Price: I do not remember
Usage: 10 months

Now 3 not-so-favorite ones:

4. Artdeco Long Lasting Liquid Liner # 03


My opinion: The arrows are weak in drawing - not bright, you have to draw 2 times, but from 2-3 times its color appears well. After rinsing, a gray trace remains. Persistent.
Grade: 3
Price: I do not remember
Usage: 6 months

5. NYX FELT TIP LINER # 02 DARK BROWN



My opinion: Nice deep color. Draws one arrow at once, and even then not always, then you need to put on a cap and shake it a little. If you overdo it, it may leak.
Grade: 3
Price: in the region of 300 rubles.
Usage: it is my second, in total - 2 years.

6. REVLON ColorStay Liquid Eye pen # 03 Blackened Brown



My opinion: Declared as dark brown, alas - it looks more like gray-brown, and there is much more gray in it. Also not bright, the color appears from the 3rd application. Not very persistent, slowly disappears by the end of the day. Also, when drawing the second arrow, you need to shake it a little (in the cap, of course) and also, if you overdo it, it may leak.
During the photo session, it flowed by itself
Grade: 3-
Price: 15 dollars (Dyutik)
Usage: 2 months

Now let's do a little experiment.

1. Traced her finger:

As you can see, 1,3,4 survived.

2. Water procedures with rubbing without pressure:

1 and 3 are not how much, the rest are so-so. A gray trail remained from Artdeko.

3. Washing off from Loreal TrioActive (for sensitive eyes) - also passed without pressure

Only the 1st passed this test, I washed it off only with 2-phase DEMAQUILLANT from Letual.
Artdeko, pale, but still in place.